Saturday, July 27, 2013

Sexism in Cover Images

I've never read anything J.K. Rowling has written, and I don't consider myself a fan of hers. But I still think this is bullshit.

So, Rowling released a gritty crime thriller (level of grit undetermined) under the name Robert Galbraith. It got decent reviews, but flopped, until she came forth as the author. Here is the cover released when nobody had reason to think Galbraith was female:



Kind of a typical crime cover, showing the shadowy male protagonist quite grittily walking away down a fog-filled London street. Fences to symbolize the fences we put up around ourselves, blah blah. I don't love the cover, it looks a little bland to me, but it clearly marks the book as a crime novel.

Here's the second printing after the big reveal. Name's still Robert Galbraith, but oh, the differences:



You can almost see a little phantom Oprah sticker in the upper corner. While I haven't read the book, and don't plan to, I have no idea WTF this cover has to do with the contents of the book. A lady's back? There's some kind of camera thing on the right, but this doesn't at all say "crime novel" or "gritty" or even "slightly gritty" to me. And of course, flowery cursive writing, the kind of thing women love. Women, am I right?

Yeah, it's possible that given Rowling's stature she had input on every stage of the cover design process, or at least veto power. Maybe this doesn't bother anyone else. But I haven't seen a side-by-side comparison of these covers yet, so hey, I've got this one.

It sucks that books with women on the cover, with flowery cursive writing, aren't taken more seriously. But they just aren't. As it looks now, this cover is heavily coded female, and if it were a crime book by an unknown female writer, I would fully expect it to tank due to its insides not matching up with its outsides (probably?) and looking like the kind of book many people would be embarrassed to pick up. I have zero interest in self-publishing, but this kind of explains why some female writers choose to do it.

9 comments:

  1. Okay, totally have to disagree with you here.

    I didn't read the book, but my wife did and from what I understand the crime or murder mystery is about a starlet (the "Cuckoo" in the title in fact). So the cover is totally relevant to the book.

    To me, the first cover looks more "self-pub" and the second cover looks more...I don't know. Polished? More than male / female, it's more a dichotomy of first time author / bestseller. To me, the first cover looks like something a small press would put out, or a major publisher who didn't want to put a lot of money behind a first timer.

    I don't know, maybe that's just me.

    But if anything, I think the first one looks "girlier" (something about the green to purple color scheme), and the second one looks more like "hey dudes, this book totally has chicks in it!"

    ReplyDelete
  2. What do I say about your posts? I love them. I read them everyday and always wait for new ones. I am very happy because I have something interesting to read. Hope you can upload more and more.
    free game brutalmaniaio
    disney bridesmaids hair salon funny
    best game goalkeeper champ

    ReplyDelete
  3. What do I say about your posts? I love them. I read them everyday and always wait for new ones. I am very happy because I have something interesting to read. Hope you can upload more and more.
    basketball 2018 games for girls
    draw play 3 games to play
    bicycle simulator unblocked games

    ReplyDelete
  4. You know what? I really like your posts. I wander on the internet to find something new or unique. And I see your articles. I decided to linger at your site and read more and more. I hope that you can upload new posts. I will be the first one to read them. Thanks a million
    rise up up games
    snail bob 7 fantasy story free
    red ball 5 online

    ReplyDelete
  5. You know what? I really like your posts. I wander on the internet to find something new or unique. And I see your articles. I decided to linger at your site and read more and more. I hope that you can upload new posts. I will be the first one to read them. Thanks a million
    rise up up games
    snail bob 7 fantasy story free
    red ball 5 online

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experiences.jogos friv gratis 2019
    Jogos 2019
    jogos friv

    ReplyDelete
  7. One of the provocative theories, suggested by Michael Wood, is that Shakespeare's most severe separation anxiety, in response to the possibility of his parting with the Young Man has its roots in his parental grief: the boy-lover is a transmutation of the dead son, adolescent and now, lost.
    kizi free online Games
    free games
    friv free Games 2019

    ReplyDelete
  8. like this post because it contains a lot of useful information to read, maybe everyone will like me. I hope this post of yours will be more appreciated by it really excellent, i enjoyed it, thanks for posting it.

    jogos io 2019
    friv Games play
    a10 games

    ReplyDelete